Initial consultation
All Insights

Asset management mandate or self-directed investing: an objective comparison

Invest yourself or award a discretionary mandate? A comparison in terms of time, discipline, custodian bank, account management and reporting.

Draft for technical and editorial review by CAM Schweiz AG, not yet approved.

Two paths to the same goal

Anyone investing assets faces a fundamental decision: invest yourself or entrust the management to a professional asset manager. Both paths have their merits. Which one suits you better depends on your time, your interest, your experience and, not least, your personality.

Self-directed investing: full control, full responsibility

Self-directed investing offers maximum freedom. You decide yourself when to buy or sell what. For investors with sound knowledge, sufficient time and a clear strategy, this can be a viable path.

At the same time, self-directed investing brings challenges:

  • Time commitment: Markets, companies and portfolios need to be monitored continuously.
  • Discipline: In turbulent phases, it is difficult to stick to a strategy and not react emotionally.
  • Structuring: Diversification, rebalancing and risk management require method and consistency.
  • Overview: With several accounts or banks, it is easy to lose sight of the overall picture.

The discretionary mandate: clear roles

With a discretionary asset management mandate, you and the asset manager jointly define the investment strategy: objectives, risk profile, investment horizon and any restrictions. Within this framework, the asset manager makes the individual investment decisions without agreeing each transaction with you in advance.

At CAM, these decisions are made by the investment committee. This enables a structured approach aligned with the strategy and ongoing monitoring of the portfolio. A mandate does not eliminate risks. However, it can help to implement decisions consistently and free from short-term emotions. CAM recommends an investment horizon of, depending on the strategy, at least 7 to 10 years for equity-heavy portfolios.

The role of the custodian bank and your account

A key feature of independent asset management in Switzerland is the separation between management and custody:

  1. Your account and custody account are in your name and are held at a Swiss custodian bank.
  2. The custodian bank holds the assets in custody and executes the transactions.
  3. CAM merely receives a limited trading power of attorney within the scope of the agreed mandate.
  4. CAM has no authority to withdraw assets or to transfer them to third parties.

This division creates transparency and clear responsibilities. CAM is licensed by FINMA as an asset manager and is supervised by the supervisory organisation OSFINcontrol AG.

Reporting and transparency

With a mandate, you receive two independent sources of information: the statements from your custodian bank and the asset manager’s reporting. The latter shows the performance of your portfolio, the allocation across asset classes and compliance with the agreed strategy. Regular meetings provide an opportunity to discuss changes in your situation and to adjust the strategy if necessary.

What suits you?

There is no universal answer. Some investors combine both approaches and manage a smaller portion themselves. Others value deliberately not having to deal with the markets every day while still being informed at all times. What matters is that the chosen solution suits your needs, the costs are transparent and you feel comfortable with it.

We would be pleased to explain in a personal initial consultation how an asset management mandate with CAM is structured.

Start the Portfolio Check

Advertising. This information is provided solely for informational and advertising purposes and constitutes neither an investment recommendation nor an offer. Investments in financial instruments and crypto assets involve risks; a partial or total loss of the capital invested is possible. Past performance is not a reliable indicator of future results. For further information, please see the legal information.

Read more

More articles.

All Insights

Contact

Let’s talk about your wealth and your goals.

Personal, discreet and without obligation.